Catering For All Occasions!
Elevate your event with our catering services. We accommodate both personal and corporate occasions, offering seamless options for delivery or pickup. Place your order conveniently online or call the store!
PizzaStarMiddletown, NY
Old fashioned tomato pie, specialty pizzas, pasta, and family favorites on Route 211. Dine in, take out, or order online for pickup and delivery.
Order for pickup or delivery
Place your order online for pickup or delivery — same kitchen, same recipes.
Order Online!
Pizza Star has made ordering online as simple as it has ever been. Just click Order Online and customize your order. In a few clicks you can go from hungry to anticipating Middletown's favorite tomato pie!
Dine in or Take Out!
Pizza Star is a family restaurant with a casual ambience and indoor dining on Route 211. The menu is full of Italian specialties including pizza, grandma pies, hot and cold sandwiches, pasta, chicken, and more!
Menu Highlights
Browse favorites from our Middletown kitchen — then order the full menu online.
Visit Us
Find us on Route 211 in Middletown for lunch, dinner, takeout, or delivery.
Family Italian on Route 211
Warm booth seating, a full Italian menu, and old fashioned tomato pie — open for dine-in, takeout, and delivery.
- Dine in, takeout, and delivery
- Open 7 days a week
- Catering for parties and corporate events
Fresh pies, ready when you are
Stop by the counter for hot specialty slices, garlic knots, and the day's fresh-baked pies.
- 400 NY-211, Middletown, NY 10940
- (845) 381-5134
- Sun–Thu 10am–10pm · Fri–Sat 10am–11pm
Leave a Google Review
Had a great meal? A quick Google review helps neighbors in Middletown discover Pizza Star.
★★★★★
Share The Love
Tell others about your visit. Your review helps our neighbors find us.
